Mastro's City Hall Steakhouse

bone-in filet

Positive
Negative

Positive 11

  • We had the bone-in filet which is pretty unbeatable. - Eleanor
  • Best Bone-In Filet Mignon ever. - Cassel
  • The bone-in filet is probably my favorite...always cooked just right. - Chris
  • Sure enough I was served with a great bone-in filet, creamed spinach, and an awesome butter cake. - Shirley
  • Best steak I've ever had (bone-in filet). - David
  • Bone-in filet & lobster mash are divine. - Erik
  • Bone-in filet is the best steak there. - Mike
  • The bone-in filet is the probably the best thing I've ever ate. - Illy
  • I also ordered the bone-in filet which was delicious, tender, cooked to perfection (which is hard to find). - Ernesto
  • I got their signature bone-in filet and it was fabulous. - Steve

Negative 0

steak

Positive
Negative

Positive 58

  • Great bartenders, strong drinks, good ,usic, great people watching and amazing steak ! - L
  • Really fantastic steak place. - C
  • Best Steak Ever. - R
  • Excellent high quality steak house . - Doug
  • Best steak house bar none! - Kevin
  • The steak was done perfectly, very very tender and every bite was delicious. - Holly
  • I went to mastro's scottsdale steakhouse and it was fantastic..the steak was delicious and the lobster was excellent. - Diana
  • I really love steak. - Daniel
  • Incredible steak and sides. - Matthew
  • Best steak in town! - Christian

Negative 7

  • I have to say that this has to be the most unreasonably over priced steak house I have ever been to. - John
  • I guess we will go to another Steak House where we will get the attention we deserve. - L.
  • At this point I felt so awkward, I didn't ask to change the steak because I don't want to be so difficult TWICE. - Irene
  • I'll chalk that insult up to a rookie waiter, but no excuse on the pedestrian steak at what purports to be a top quality steak joint. - RW
  • No intimate romantic dining here but if you want a good steak and want to take a group out to dinner this is definitely your place. - Michelle
  • And if this is a steak house.. they should really perfect medium rare. - Irene
  • By far the best steak I have ever had. - Smashely

live music

Positive
Negative

Positive 12

  • Great crowd, live music, professional servers, wonderful menu. - Christina
  • Great service and I recommend dining in the lounge with live music for a fun atmosphere. - Josh
  • Good experience, good service, beautiful facility, live music, and the food....oh - the yummy food! - Kayla
  • The live music is a great touch too. - Brandon
  • Live music in the bar was a great addition. - The A
  • Started off the evening in the circular bar at the front with live music - great way to enjoy a cocktail before dinner. - Colleen
  • If you're up for a bit of a scene, some live music and great people watching, I highly recommend sitting in the bar. - Gabi
  • We were able to enjoy the live music throughout dinner. - J
  • This place has the ambiance, live music, service, and delicious food. - Sandy
  • Live entertainment; pianist and singer with perfect selection of music to fit the fare! - Terry

Negative 0

service

Positive
Negative

Positive 106

  • amazing food great bar wonderful service - Mary
  • FAST prompt service, great coctails, great wine list. - James
  • Classy atmosphere, great food good service. - Eric
  • excellent service. - Joe
  • Great service, great atmosphere. - Jay
  • Service is spectacular, with knowledgeable and attentive servers. - Rose
  • Great service, better food. - john
  • Remarkable service. - Andre
  • Incredible service. - Daniel
  • Great service! - Tracey

Negative 9

  • Horrible and rude service! - L.
  • Inattentive and condescending service. - Andrew
  • We keep going back because all our friends love this place, but have never once had good service and this time even the food was off. - Christiane
  • I was totally put off by the lack of customer service we were given regarding the wait. - Smashely
  • The service definitely waned as we made our discontent known. - Derek
  • I'm not sure how I feel about this place yet, the filet was REALLY good but the service threw off the experience. - Irene
  • As to food, I'm plenty happy with the steaks at Ruth's Chris to risk suffering through their uninviting dining room and elitist service again. - Andrew
  • Not really impressed with the service but the food was great. - L
  • The service was mediocre, the dining area is always very loud, and the food was not the quality I have had there in the past. - Tiffany

restaurant

Positive
Negative

Positive 11

  • The interior has a nice feel to it: classy, modern, yet understated enough so you know you're in a special restaurant. - EV
  • great restaurant... just ate here Sunday night...Good bar atmosphere, and great food and service. - wine
  • Other yelpers have done a great job describing the restaurant so I'll skip that and make some food recommendations. - Morgan
  • This is the BEST restaurant I've had the pleasure of experiencing in Arizona, hands down. - Donna
  • 5/2013 Update: We returned to this wonderful restaurant, and it was even better than the first time we went. - Dave
  • This is the best restaurant in Scottsdale. - Aaron
  • best restaurant hands down, my bf & mine FAV my bf and i have been here prob over 50 times. - Mary
  • My hubby ditched his cobbler and proceeded to devour my warm butter cake, stating it was the best dessert he'd ever had at a restaurant. - Melanie
  • This is what every fancy restaurant should be like. - tiffany
  • Regardless of what kind of restaurant you are at, this is always a nice touch. - Stacy

Negative 5

  • We were told by a couple that was leaving that Mastro's will allow people to cut in if they know someone that works in the restaurant. - John
  • Crab cakes were tasty but not as good as another restaurant in town that were amazing (eddie v's)! - adam
  • Yes it was a crazy night, but it was a Saturday night in December and anyone with anytime in the restaurant industry knows what that means. - William
  • The lobster mashed potatoes, like the rest of the experience in the restaurant, wasn't bad. - Lucky
  • Ten years ago, a restaurant could get away with this, but not now. - Toni

pretzel bread

Positive
Negative

Positive 6

  • Bread service is fabulous with my favorite, the pretzel bread, and sides are in family-size portions. - Rose
  • I especially love the pretzel bread. - Kelley
  • Love the pretzel bread that they put out on the table as well. - Chris
  • We enjoyed delicious pretzel bread, crunchy Cesar salad, filet, macaroni and cheese and Lobster mashed potatoes. - Lindsey
  • We started with wonderful (free) breads and our server warned us the pretzel bread is addictive. - Dave
  • Great steaks and love the pretzel bread. - Ken

Negative 1

  • I was only going to give it 1 star but the bread (especially the pretzel bread and the olive bread) and wine were at least good! - Hootie

seafood tower

Positive
Negative

Positive 6

  • He was knowledgeable about the wine menu and recommended an awesome bottle to go with our seafood tower. - Laura
  • He made an excellent wine recommendation and helped us choose the apps for our seafood tower. - Stacy
  • The seafood tower featured totally fresh and delicious oysters, crab legs, claws, and huge shrimp. - Fred
  • seafood tower is my fav! - Olivia
  • Seafood tower rocks and, I've said it 3-4 different times now, BEST STEAK I'VE EVER HAD. - Christopher
  • We started out with the seafood tower, it was an awesomely big tower of lobster, crab, shrimp, and oysters -- all were outstanding. - Matt

Negative 0

warm butter cake

Positive
Negative

Positive 7

  • The famous Warm Butter Cake! - Thai
  • Warm butter cake! - Kevin
  • As for dessert, the warm butter cake is amazing. - Danielle
  • * Warm Butter Cake - The dessert menu is large and has many appealing choices. - EV
  • If somehow you are able to have room for dessert, I highly recommend the warm butter cake. - Josh
  • My hubby ditched his cobbler and proceeded to devour my warm butter cake, stating it was the best dessert he'd ever had at a restaurant. - Melanie
  • You have to order a steak for your main course and the warm butter cake is the perfect finale. - E

Negative 0

top notch

Positive
Negative

Positive 16

  • top notch - Paul
  • Top notch! - Cristy
  • It was a really top notch recovery. - Fred
  • Everything we ate was top notch, the atmosphere is fun, and the service is spectacular. - Fred
  • Filet - top notch. - Turf
  • The service is top notch and the food is even better. - Michael
  • Service is top notch and the food is the best quality I've found in the state and beyond. - Gabi
  • The staff is always top notch. - Amy
  • Food and service are top notch here. - Lonnie
  • Our server also was top notch and professional. - EV

Negative 0

server

Positive
Negative

Positive 18

  • The service was outstanding, extremely knowledgeable server with very helpful suggestions. - Laurie
  • The atmosphere is great, the food was amazing and our server Jenn was excellent! - Jeanette
  • The server (Andrew) was very attentive and friendly. - Kari
  • Our server was great. - Laura
  • Our server was awesome. - Stacy
  • Our server was fabulous--timed everything perfectly. - candee
  • He is a great server. - Jay
  • Our server was as good as the food, she made great suggestions and was very accommodating . - Jason
  • Our server also was top notch and professional. - EV
  • Our server was friendly and polite the whole evening, even as it got quite busy. - Katie

Negative 4

  • We would have complained to our server if we ever saw her! - Hootie
  • Our server was not around as much as we would have liked him to be. - Lucky
  • If I had a question about what one or two of the desserts were, it was irrelevant because our server was nowhere to be found. - Lucky
  • Our server didn't suggest any of the more popular cuts of meat, didn't show us the raw tray. - Lucky

order

Positive
Negative

Positive 9

  • So just sip and enjoy, you'll probably only order 2 at most unless you're a lush). - Blair
  • The butter cake with fresh berries and made to order whipped cream is a heavenly dream. - W
  • Our steaks were cooked perfectly to order. - Chris
  • But in the long run she got our food right and had it to us in the proper order and keep my tea full! - Evan
  • The wine list is top notch with the classics as well as new ones to try and don't forget to order some port after dinner! - Dawn
  • You have to order a steak for your main course and the warm butter cake is the perfect finale. - E
  • I usually order 1 and call it good. - Chris
  • If you prefer medium rare, order it rare. - Cheryl
  • We had a wonderful female server who suggested wine and appetizers and specials, the perfect server, until we order the wine. - Evan

Negative 0

dining room

Positive
Negative

Positive 6

  • Cool dining room, great steaks, and creamed spinach- my favorite! - Eric
  • Then we made our way toward the dark, chic, modern yet classic dining room. - Colleen
  • The dining room is beautiful. - sarah
  • For a more romantic cozy dinner we sit in the dining room. - W
  • Good feel to the dining room, and service was good at 8PM on a Friday night. - Chris
  • The dining room is dimly lit and intimate. - Kevin

Negative 1

  • As to food, I'm plenty happy with the steaks at Ruth's Chris to risk suffering through their uninviting dining room and elitist service again. - Andrew

lobster

Positive
Negative

Positive 11

  • I went to mastro's scottsdale steakhouse and it was fantastic..the steak was delicious and the lobster was excellent. - Diana
  • I've never heard anyone complain about the signature lobster mashed potatoes either. - Gabi
  • Bone-in filet & lobster mash are divine. - Erik
  • The filet and lobster mash are my favorite. - Sabrina
  • I'm salivating just thinking about the lobster mash, oh yea the steak is pretty fabulous too. - Michael
  • We enjoyed delicious pretzel bread, crunchy Cesar salad, filet, macaroni and cheese and Lobster mashed potatoes. - Lindsey
  • The small stringy pieces of lobster was a nice addition to a doughy gnocchi entree. - Albie
  • The lobster was the best I have ever had. - The A
  • I loved those chunks of lobster in my potatoes, it was probably one of the best side dishes I've ever tried. - Krys
  • We started out with the seafood tower, it was an awesomely big tower of lobster, crab, shrimp, and oysters -- all were outstanding. - Matt

Negative 4

  • We ordered a bone in rib eye, bone in filet, and lobster mashed potatoes. - Irene
  • The lobster mashed potatoes, like the rest of the experience in the restaurant, wasn't bad. - Lucky
  • The lobster mashed potatoes: I do not know what the big deal is. - Lucky
  • Lobster mashed potatoes- This was packed with flavor and chunks and chunks of lobster, really amazing. - Irene

city hall

Positive
Negative

Positive 19

  • City Hall does it right....fantastic steaks....fantastic service. - Bob
  • City Hall delivers very well in that regard. - EV
  • I just happen to prefer City Hall because of the convenient location to where I live and work! - Gabi
  • Mastro's City Hall was awesome! - Melanie
  • Wolfgang's in NY still gets my top place but Mastro's City Hall is great. - Matthew
  • I am so loyal to Durant's that I feel like a heel...but City Hall was divine. - Moki
  • I highly recommend Mastro's city hall. - Alexandra
  • There are many choices for a great meal in Scottsdale, but Mastro's City Hall is at the top of the list. - Cindy
  • Everything is right about City Hall. - Shimain
  • City Hall is arguably my favorite steakhouse EVER. - Asina

Negative 2

  • The management at the City Hall in Scottsdale should be ashamed. - William
  • At City Hall it was cooked all the way through and it really ruined it for me. - Hootie

place

Positive
Negative

Positive 64

  • Very nice and classy place. - Joan
  • Great place! - Rob
  • A nice place for a celebration. - Jason
  • Really fantastic steak place. - C
  • It's also a great place to celebrate! - Sarah
  • Very hot bar scene and great people watching place. - Chris
  • A really great place! - Kevin
  • It's the perfect place for a special dinner out or a great place to enjoy a drink and fresh shellfish in the bar/ lounge area. - Morgan
  • A wonderful place to celebrate a special event for sure! - Melanie
  • This place is a great treat and has a fabulous atmosphere. - Alyssa

Negative 5

  • We keep going back because all our friends love this place, but have never once had good service and this time even the food was off. - Christiane
  • If we wanted to go that route we would have just walked in and snagged a table in the bar in the first place. - Smashely
  • I'm not sure how I feel about this place yet, the filet was REALLY good but the service threw off the experience. - Irene
  • It's supposed to be an amazing place, but we didn't get helped at the bar. - L.
  • No intimate romantic dining here but if you want a good steak and want to take a group out to dinner this is definitely your place. - Michelle

butter cake

Positive
Negative

Positive 17

  • The famous Warm Butter Cake! - Thai
  • Warm butter cake! - Kevin
  • The food, as usual, was outstanding and the butter cake stood up to its reputation , the wait staff impeccable . - Debbie
  • The butter cake is incredible. - The A
  • As for dessert, the warm butter cake is amazing. - Danielle
  • Sure enough I was served with a great bone-in filet, creamed spinach, and an awesome butter cake. - Shirley
  • * Warm Butter Cake - The dessert menu is large and has many appealing choices. - EV
  • Save a tiny bit of room for the butter cake...quite a nice way to wrap up such a great dinner. - Christopher
  • The butter cake with fresh berries and made to order whipped cream is a heavenly dream. - W
  • If somehow you are able to have room for dessert, I highly recommend the warm butter cake. - Josh

Negative 0

steaks

Positive
Negative

Positive 24

  • City Hall does it right....fantastic steaks....fantastic service. - Bob
  • Cool dining room, great steaks, and creamed spinach- my favorite! - Eric
  • Their steaks are dry aged and cooked perfectly, the atmosphere is great for a steakhouse, it feels alive yet intimate at the same time. - Ron
  • Service is great and the steaks are even better. - Dave
  • The service is the best just like their steaks. - Noosh
  • Prime steaks and very good service . - Doug
  • Super expensive but worth the money best steaks in the valley! - Nancy
  • The service isn't over the top like I'd expect, but I really do love the steaks. - Norma
  • The service isn't over the top like I'd expect, but I really do love the steaks. - Norma
  • The steaks are good, and they have nice options for chicken and fish eaters too! - Mardi

Negative 4

  • Our friends ordered steaks (Filet), of which I tried and found them to be sour in taste. - John
  • As to food, I'm plenty happy with the steaks at Ruth's Chris to risk suffering through their uninviting dining room and elitist service again. - Andrew
  • The steaks were good, not great. - Mike
  • The steaks were the highlight, but everything else fell a little flat. - Josh

sides

Positive
Negative

Positive 11

  • Incredible steak and sides. - Matthew
  • Bread service is fabulous with my favorite, the pretzel bread, and sides are in family-size portions. - Rose
  • The sides are also excellent. - Alexandra
  • Steamed broccoli and spinach were great sides. - Elizabeth
  • The sides were tasty as well. - Holly
  • The presentation was awesome, several servers came out to our table and presented our steaks at the same time and served our sides to us as well. - Rosalind
  • Unless you have a massive appetite, go easy on the sides! - Rose
  • Its great that they offer half sizes on salads and sides. - Kari
  • The sides are family style, every one we say looked great. - Chris
  • Then, we each got a petite filet and the mac and cheese and sweet potato fries for our sides. - Holly

Negative 0

meal

Positive
Negative

Positive 19

  • Thank you for an extraordinarily enjoyable meal. - Yvonne
  • Excellent meal! - Dave
  • Exceptional meal here. - Joe
  • You'll be paying for an amazing meal plus top-notch service. - Malika
  • Almost every element of this meal was pure heaven. - Lindsay
  • Nothing wrong with this meal. - Paul
  • The key lime pie is also a hit and a perfect way to cool off after such a heavy meal. - Dawn
  • Finally the meal was perfectly in place. - Gary
  • There are many choices for a great meal in Scottsdale, but Mastro's City Hall is at the top of the list. - Cindy
  • I look forward to another great meal at Mastro's real soon. - Yvonne

Negative 1

  • And at one point during the meal, management came over to set up the table next to us and were beyond obnoxious. - Christiane